We Are What We Choose to Be
Becoming a Homemaker is a personal choice and career decision. Many women (and some men) leave their former occupations to become Homemakers. Most people become Homemakers when they acquire and accept the responsibility of caring for a home and its occupants. Usually, other household members work outside the house to provide the Homemaker with adequate resources to care for the family.
Share the Responsibilities and Lighten the Load
When Homemakers have full-time or part-time jobs outside the home, or even if they do not, two or more household members may agree to share the work of running a home. Homemakers spend varying periods in their occupations, and the needs of every household differ.
The careers of Homemakers are flexible and diverse. A Homemaker may choose to perform general housekeeping chores and personal services or delegate them to other household members or household staff. Every household is unique, and each Homemaker’s duties vary according to criteria such as ages of family members, their habits, health, needs, preferences, and incomes.
What Do Studies Show?
Demographic studies show that choices vary for men and women about placing children/elders in care or staying at home for family duties. A significant proportion of mothers withdraw from employment after childbirth based on calculations of their ability to balance work and family responsibilities.
Worldwide, more than a quarter of adults – 27% of women and 29% of men – prefer families with stay-at-home women. Developing countries in South Asia and the Middle East, including Bangladesh and Pakistan, have relatively high proportions of adults who like women to play homemakers’ roles. In contrast, developed countries in Europe, including Denmark, Italy, and Sweden, generally have relatively low proportions of adults with such preferences. In between are developing and developed countries such as Brazil, China, Russia, and the United States, where about one-quarter of men and women prefer families with stay-at-home women.
Generally, men have higher rates of preference for stay-at-home women, but not always. In Denmark, India, Japan, and Sweden, women’s preferences for families with women as Homemakers exceed those of men. Preferences for stay-at-home women also vary by age group. Women and men aged 30 years and over have more significant preferences for stay-at-home women than those below age 30. Childbirth and child-rearing are critical factors behind such preferences.
Practical considerations, including childcare costs and lack of access to suitable facilities, also play a role. In the United States, for example, childcare can cost more than college. With no government option for young children’s care, nearly 60 percent of American parents report that they cannot find reliable, affordable childcare near their homes.
Research done across 28 countries shows a small but statistically significant and robust happiness advantage for Homemakers compared to full-time working wives. With Homemakers holding their own, the antiquated notion that homemaking is a thankless job finds less support today.
Increasing awareness that employment does not equal satisfaction is fueled by media valorization of Homemakers and intensive parenting. Several mediating variables such as the family income, the perceived fairness of the division of household labor, number of children in the household, gender ideology, religious services attendance, and family stress are significantly related to the happiness Homemakers experience.
Most women and men worldwide no longer subscribe to the proverb “a woman’s place is in the home” and prefer that women pursue paid employment. Nevertheless, gender differences and human reproduction will likely result in more women playing the Homemaker role than men.